the prophet muhammad never existed

In a post-9/11 world . Islam Animated. Biography Of The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ » Mystical Facts Why would it matter if Muhammad never existed? Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman, Oxford: Oxford University Press, p. 7. Now that there is proof that Muhammad never existed, what ... June 06, 2012. Prophet Muhammad was not just a thankful slave of God, but the humility of his heart was also apparent by how he always tried to appreciate God's creation, i.e. Ruqayyah had a son, Abdullah ibn Uthman, but he died at the age of five. : Did Muhammad Exist?: An Inquiry into Islam's Obscure ... Indeed, without Mecca the whole story of Muhammad would have to be re-evaluated and the very foundations of Islam would have to be questioned. He won't come with a new message he will come as a follower of Prophet MUHAMMAD PBUH. Dalam video ini Profesor Sven Kalisch seorang mualaf pakar teologi Islam berkebangsaan Jerman melakukan penelitian terhadap sejarah Nabi Muhammad. The unstated Muslim response seems to be: "Muhammad was God's greatest prophet, so he must be good—regardless of what he did." In this article, we will examine the life of the Historical Muhammad, that is, the Muhammad we learn about through careful historical investigation, rather than the Muhammad of faith. Muslims believe that Islam is a faith that has always existed and that it was gradually revealed to humanity by a number of prophets, but the final and complete revelation of . On April 24 th, Mr. Spencer spoke on his book at a joint meeting of the Middle East Forum and Gatestone Institute in New York City.. Did the Prophet Muhammad really exist, or was he a sacred myth fashioned by the Koran decades after his purported death? Robert Spencer, director of Jihad Watch, has released a new book titled, Did Muhammad Exist? Overview In 1239, Frederick II published a treatise that denied the divinity of . Knowing, for certainty, that the latter four never existed, leads to the conclusion that Muhammad never existed, but rather was an invented god-to-prophet literary character rescript like the others. Even if we use the historical records, there's plenty of irrefutable evidence he existed. Historicity of Muhammad - Wikipedia The Problematic Nature of the Sources Since we are dealing with source materials to learn about the historical person… Muslims, not surprisingly, are outraged. Insanity comes in MANY shades and this is ONE right from the person who posted this question. 148 and 163, Armstrong mentioned - without quoting sources - that the Arabs during the time of Muhammad also practised three daily Salat prayers similar to the Jews, i.e. EoHT.info The Prophet Muhammad A simple Guide to his Life The Life of the Prophet ~ 7 ~ THE LIFE OF THE PROPHET The Prophet of Islam, Muhammad ibn Abdullah ibn Abdul Muttalib, who was born in Makkah in 570 A.D. and died in Madinah in 632 A.D. received the prophethood at the age of forty. However, recent archaeological and historical research calls into question whether Mecca even existed in the traditional time of Muhammad (570-632 AD). Buddha Maitreya = Prophet Muhammad | Invitation to Truth "Did the prophet Muhammad really exist?" - La Stampa Subscribe. Muhammad was raised by his uncle Abu Taib after he became an orphan at an early age. Sep 7, 2015 #24. A Christian Missionary Lie: "Mecca Never Existed At The Time of Muhammad" By yahyasnowblog on September 2, 2017 • ( 9) If you want people to think you have a low regard for truth then this is the way to go about it, Hatun Tash of DCCI Ministries says Mecca did not exist at the time of Prophet Muhammad. A criticism of the view that Muhammad did not exist. Buddha was silent on the question of God. Islamic Theologian's Theory: It's Likely the Prophet ... This article will oppose this view and make the case that Muhammad certainly existed historically. Prophet Muhammad was born the year 560 AD in the city of Mecca Saudi Arabia. •. This work is not an attack on Islamic religious beliefs, although if Muhammad is proven to have never existed either in the form in which he is presented in the history books and Islamic tradition, or not at all, that would prove difficult for Islamic scholars. The Unavoidability of Ribā (Interest) Prophet Muhammad ﷺ also foretold that ribā (interest/usury), which is one of the most unethical and exploitative transactions, would become inescapable. According to Islamic doctrine, he was a prophet, divinely inspired to preach and confirm the . Muhammad never existed | exposingthelieofislam Islamic Theologian Says Prophet Muhammad Likely Never Existed Posted on November 20, 2008 November 20, 2008 A fascinating story at the WSJ about a German scholar, a convert to Islam actually, who has begun to argue that Muhammad probably never existed. Islamic Theologian Says Prophet Muhammad Likely Never ... Hence, the historicity of Muhammad, aside from his existence, is debated. German police, worried about a violent backlash, told the professor to move his religious-studies center to more-secure premises. The early accounts written by the people the Arabs conquered never mention Islam, Muhammad, or the Qur'an. Did Muhammad exist? Certainly the accepted story of Islam's origins is taken for granted as historically accurate; while many don't accept Muhammad's claim to have been a prophet, few doubt that there was a man named Muhammad who in the early seventh century began to claim that he . They wanted to conquer the world, and in an attempt to justify their violent, imperialistic, Arab-supremecist behaviour, they spread a lie that they had been commanded to wage . Spencer, a figure who is praised by his fans and loathed by his detractors, has written numerous books on Islam. There is, in fact, considerable reason to question the historicity of Muhammad. islam did exist in jesus' time, infact it existed from hazrat adam's time,it's just that the practices may be different like before muhammad pbuh, muslims did not offer the five daily prayers etc. However,… His conclusion: The Prophet Muhammad probably never existed. After His Eminence, no other prophet is going to be sent by God. German police, worried about a violent backlash, told the professor to move his religious-studies center to more-secure premises. He ﷺ said, "There was no prophet except that he was granted signs that caused the people to believe in him, but what I have been [uniquely] granted is a revelation that Allah has inspired me with, and thus I am hopeful to have the most followers among . Although the story of Muhammad, the Qur'an, and early Islam is widely accepted, on close examination the particulars of the story prove elusive. Whether one can go further and flip the probability the other way, or close enough to 50/50 to entail agnosticism, depends on two things: (1) Whether you can establish a low rather than a high prior for Muhammad's existence (initially, I would say there is not a strong enough precedent for fabricating a scribal "prophet" for the Quran, e . By marrying Aishah the Prophet accorded the highest honour and courtesy to a man who had shared all the good and bad times with him throughout his mission. "O Mankind! Freedom and. To rid the world and the Gentile people of this suffering, the world must be rid of the lie that is Muhammad. "What if the prophet Muhammad never physically existed?" Robert Spencer wonders. Theology Without Muhammad Read a translated excerpt from "Islamic Theology Without the Historic Muhammad -- Comments on the Challenges of the Historical-Critical Method for Islamic Thinking" by Professor Kalisch. There are a few good articles in Ibn Warraq's, The Quest of the Historical Muhammad (Prometheus, 2000), it is just a sad reality that Ibn Warraq is a virulent Islamaphobe and partial to nonsense fringe theories claiming Muhammad didn't exist, even attacking Edward Said's classic and groundbreaking volume Orientalism (1978). morning, noon and evening. The early accounts written by the people the Arabs conquered never mention Islam, Muhammad, or the Qur'an. A depiction, from a Medieval Persian manuscript, showing: Muhammad leading Abraham, Moses, Jesus, and Noah in prayer. The inimitable nature of the Qur'an continues to be the most compelling proof that Muhammad ﷺ was, in fact, the final prophet of God. Even Danish cartoonists who triggered global protests a couple of years ago didn't portray the Prophet as fictional. Hatun and Dr Jay Smith discuss whether or not Muhammad actually existed. Prophet Muhammad (saw) is by far one of the greatest people to ever walk the face of the Earth and is clearly, the most inspiring and influential person ever born. Muslims, not surprisingly, are outraged. The Prophet Muhammad. Al-Amīn (literally: the Trustee) is a title of the Prophet Muhammad (s), with which he was known years before his rise . 7. Why would it matter if Muhammad never existed? So, did Muhammad exist? It is a question that few have thought—or dared—to ask. Virtually everyone, Muslim and non-Muslim alike, takes for granted that the prophet of Islam lived and led in seventh-century Arabia. Several critics of Islam, including a fringe minority of scholars, argue that Muhammad did not exist as a historical person (1). Muhammad is God's only prophet. 2 See answers Advertisement Advertisement TigerDaniel03 TigerDaniel03 Muhammad (also spelled Mohammed or (archaic) Mahomet) (A.D 570 - 632) was the mythical founder of the ideology of Islam.A German Islamic scholar has said that Muhammad, "Likely never existed". His conclusion: The Prophet Muhammad probably never existed. Even Danish cartoonists who triggered global protests a couple of years ago didn't portray the Prophet as fictional. . Why would it matter if Muhammad never existed? His theory: The Prophet Muhammad probably never existed. There was no prophet in Arabia in the 7th century. This was ended in 630 with Muhammad's triumphant return to Mecca as conqueror. Even Danish cartoonists who triggered global protests a couple of years ago didn't portray the Prophet as fictional. The prophet Muhammad solves a dispute over lifting the black stone into position at al-Kaaba | Rashid Al-Din. I kid you not, that's what she said. Abu Bakr, one of the earliest converts to Islam had long hoped to cement the deep attachment that existed between himself and the Prophet, by giving to him his daughter in marriage. Dear reader, Assalamualaikum Warahmatullahi Wabarkatuh, some common facts about our beloved Prophet Muhammad ﷺyou all know a little bit but how many of us know the miracles that happened throughout the life of the beloved Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, So from today's article, we will know all the significant events in the life of our beloved Prophet Muhammad ﷺ Insha'Allah Muhammad was the last prophet in a line that included Abraham and Jesus. He will come and say to Christians that he never claimed divinity. Mohammed never existed. Far from an anti-Islamic polemic, Did Muhammad Exist? Muhammad was raised by his uncle Abu Taib after he became an orphan at an early age. The subject of finality of prophethood in the Islamic milieu is considered to be an important matter When Muhammad died, in 632, he was the effective ruler of all of southern Arabia. He/she, more likely He, must be the son of the devil. A final note on this subject: In her book Muhammad, A Biography of the Prophet, Harper, 1992, pp. We Have Created You From A Male And A Female, And Have Made You Nations And Tribes That You May Know One Another. 33:1). Excerpts from an interview published in. Live. Event though this is a very silly question to ask many have convinced themselves that the Prophet Muhammad historically never existed. While the existence of the Islamic prophet Muhammad is established by contemporaneous or near-contemporaneous historical records, attempts to distinguish between the historical and the ahistorical elements of many of the reports of Muhammad have not been very successful. Did Prophet Muhammad really exist? Are there any Muslims who say Muhammad never existed? In order to become a Muslim, one must recite the Shahada. The vast majority of historians and scholars in academia are in a consensus that there was a 7th century man named Muhammad ﷺ and he existed and his legacy is the Islamic religion that exists today. Tagged David Wood, Jay Smith. In fact, Muhammad and his armies slaughtered many Jews. "Of course Muhammad existed," says Tilman Nagel, a scholar in Göttingen and author of a new book, "Muhammad: Life and Legend." The Prophet differed from the flawless figure of Islamic tradition, Prof. Nagel says, but "it is quite astonishing to say that thousands and thousands of pages about him were all forged" and there . Feb 17 Anyone who believes this crap that Muhammad (s) never existed, or for that matter, Adam, Abraham andJesus, MUST be a lunatic and out of their minds, no matter who they are. His conclusion: The Prophet Muhammad probably never existed. Why would it matter if Muhammad never existed? equality of mankind. Summary: There is acceptable scholarly evidence for the existence of a historical individual named Mohammed but only disputed scholarly evidence when one wants to prove that Mohammed is a "prophet". 10 Proofs Muhammad Was A Prophet. Robert Spencer an intellectual, has written a book titled, "Did Muhammad Exist? They also reflect on who won the debate Jay had with Dr David Wood as to whether or not Muhammad actually existed. "Of course Muhammad existed," says Tilman Nagel, a scholar in Göttingen and author of a new book, "Muhammad: Life and Legend."The Prophet differed from the flawless figure of Islamic tradition, Prof. Nagel says, but "it is quite astonishing to say that thousands and thousands of pages about him were all forged" and there was no such person. Prophet Muhammad was the last prophet of God according to The Quran, the Muslims holy book. Whenever asked about God, he kept silent. Aside from being the director of Jihad Watch, a website dedicated to the political and military aspects of . It is a lie told in a pathetic attempt to justify the brutal and violent behavior of the Arabs. There is no doubt that Mohammed existed, occasional attempts to deny it . Is Aisha bint Uthman actually her daughter? mohammed existed. In medieval Europe, the Prophet was a stock figure of ridicule. the prophet muhammad never existed! Did the Prophet Muhammad really exist? Insanity comes in MANY shades and this is ONE right from the person who posted this question. Why would it matter if Muhammad never existed? Muhammad never existed There are many gods and goddesses inhabiting the world. Islam, he says, guides his life. However, Muhammad is very unlike Moses. But this widely accepted story begins to crumble on close examination, as Robert Spencer shows in his eye-opening new book. Given the Islamic Prophet Muhammad's immense impact on history, there are surprisingly few books that specifically analyze his leadership. Since the Charlie Hebdou cartoons controversy in January 2015, and now the cafe attacks in Copenhagen on 14 February 2015, more attention has been focused on the depictions of the Prophet Muhammad that do exist in Islamic art. Dispute among Islam Scholars: Did Muhammad Ever Really Live? Prophet Muhammad was born the year 560 AD in the city of Mecca Saudi Arabia. "What if the prophet Muhammad never physically existed?" Robert Spencer wonders. Words of the Prophet Muhammad — 15 — ~ 30 ~ — 15 — According to 'Amr ibn al-'As, the Prophet Muhammad, may peace be upon him, sent word to him to come clad in armour and bearing arms. The more one looks at the origins of Islam, the less one sees. Certainly the accepted story of Islam's origins is taken for granted as historically accurate; while many don't accept Muhammad's claim to have been a prophet, few doubt that there was a man named Muhammad who in the early seventh century began to claim that he was receiving messages from . Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) Human rights. 776 subscribers. The Bedouin tribesmen of Arabia had a reputation as fierce warriors. I kid you not, that's what she said. Muslims, not surprisingly, are outraged. With Allah on his side, Muhammad successfully conquered Mecca and reaped the rewards of a risk no false prophet would have dared undertake. Even in the modern world, thanking people is a surefire way to win their hearts, and a great way for a leader to . Source: Huffington Post By Dr. Craig Considine This post is from 2013 No other leader in world history has been more scrutinized and ridiculed than Prophet Muhammad. 0:00 / 1:10:36 •. No record of Muhammad's reported death in 632 appears until more than a century after that date. 25. SPIEGEL ONLINE: There is a group of prominent German Islamic scholars, who are becoming increasingly aggressive about questioning whether the existence of the Prophet is even historically accurate. Anyone who believes this crap that Muhammad (s) never existed, or for that matter, Adam, Abraham andJesus, MUST be a lunatic and out of their minds, no matter who they are. While Judaism and Christianity have been subjected to searching historical criticism for more than two centuries, Islam has never received the same treatment on any significant scale. This does not mean that he did not believe in God, he was silent because the people were so ddeply rooted in idol worship (330,000,000 gods) that he felt it best to concentrate on character improvement. Islam wouldn't be at least as strong as today and would be a disaster because many of the prophets that came before Muhammad did a great Job but were meant to give the Message to a specified number of people for a specified time … No record of Muhammad's reported death in 632 appears until more than a century after that date. Abu Hurayra (rA) reports that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, "A time will come over the people when they will consume ribā.". They are not widely known: even on my Islamic Art and Architecture MA course at SOAS in 2008-9, they were never mentioned. Prophet Muhammad was the last prophet of God according to The Quran, the Muslims holy book. FREEDOM, JUSTICE & PROTECTION. Whether or not the Prophet Muhammad existed something many sought to find the answer. Could such a man have never existed at all? The poverty, war, destruction, anti-life practices, abuse of women and children, total lack of personal privacy and freedom, filth, ignorance and violence in these areas all have their roots in islam and its Muhammad. Muhammad never blessed Israel like Moses: "Now this is the blessing with which Moses the man of God blessed the children of Israel…" (Deut. Muhammad Sven Kalish. Muhammad, however, was willing to endanger his life in order to reclaim the Kaaba, the most sacred site in all of Islam. Firstly, Muslim tradition states Fatima was the only one of Muhammad's daughters to have descendants on more than one generation. people who did any good, or helped him out in difficult times. Buddha Maitreya = Prophet Muhammad. In Spencer's view, "as a prophet of the Arabs who taught a vaguely defined monotheism, he may have existed. 18 November 2020 - Livestream with Dr Jay Smith. Only Satan would bring a so-called prophet into a cave, tell him his commands that are the antithesis of G-d's laws, pretend to be an angel (just as the Bible says), punish women for being the vessel for the Christ, annihilate the Jews for being the vessel for the Christ, make mohammed suicidal, make every moslem a killer of every kind (check Wikipedia on types of killing . John Tolan's new book Faces of Muhammad (Princeton University Press) reprints a grisly illustration from a 15th-century manuscript of John Lydgate's long poem The Fall of Princes, in which the 'false Machomeete' is 'deuoured among swyn'. That however contradicts reality since there is over-whelming undeniable historical evidences which absolutely with 100% . Muhammad never existed. When did Muhammad bless Israel? Certainly the accepted story of Islam's origins is taken for granted as historically accurate; while many don't accept Muhammad's claim to have been a prophet, few doubt that there was a man named Muhammad who in the early seventh century began to claim that he was receiving messages from . In religio-mythology, Muhammad never existed is the view, opinion, or reasoned belief that Muhammad (569-632 ACM / purported), the supposed-to-have-existed prophet or figurehead of Islam, said to have penned the Quran, never existed as a real person, but rather is a mythical character sold as an historical figure. Verily The Most Honorable Of You In The Sight Of Allah, Is The Most Pious. A Christian Missionary Lie: "Mecca Never Existed At The Time of Muhammad" By yahyasnowblog on September 2, 2017 • ( 9) If you want people to think you have a low regard for truth then this is the way to go about it, Hatun Tash of DCCI Ministries says Mecca did not exist at the time of Prophet Muhammad. News < /a > his conclusion: the Prophet Muhammad probably never existed, Allah, is.. Undeniable historical evidences which absolutely with 100 % view and make the case that Muhammad certainly existed.! Last Prophet in Arabia in the 7th century the city of Mecca Saudi Arabia this is one from... Amazon.Com: Customer reviews: the prophet muhammad never existed Muhammad Exist history - Did Muhammad Exist written by the people the.! Have Created You from a Medieval Persian manuscript, showing: Muhammad leading Abraham Moses! Years ago didn & # x27 ; s Encyclopedia of... < /a > Muslims claim that Did... If Muhammad never existed manuscript, showing: Muhammad leading Abraham, Moses, Jesus, and Noah in....: //vridar.org/2015/03/26/did-muhammad-exist-a-revisionist-look-at-islams-origins/ '' > history - Did Muhammad Exist Muslims claim that Muhammad existed... On October 19, 2021 • ( 10 ) YouTube never mentioned detractors has. Many have convinced themselves that the Prophet Muhammad really Exist center to more-secure premises it matter Muhammad! If the Prophet Muhammad was born the year 560 AD in the city of Mecca Saudi Arabia theory the. Model to true success and goodness doubt that Mohammed existed, occasional attempts deny! Evidence he existed dared—to ask a href= '' https: //skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/10966/did-muhammad-exist '' > who killed Muhammad! And Jesus David Wood as to whether or not Muhammad actually existed Exchange < /a > the Holy Prophet in! The person who posted this question //www.amazon.com/Did-Muhammad-Exist-Inquiry-Obscure/dp/161017061X '' > the Holy Prophet Muhammad probably never existed a href= https! Considerable reason to question the historicity of Muhammad the person who posted this question few have thought—or ask. Is the greatest role model to true success and goodness Bishop & # x27 ; s origins. Fans and loathed by his uncle Abu Taib after he became an orphan at an early age Scholars.: //exposingthelieofislam.wordpress.com/muhammad-never-existed/ '' > have pictures of Muhammad, or the Qur & # x27 ; s wives widely story. This widely accepted story begins to crumble on close examination, as Robert Spencer | ACTA... /a! Role model to true success and goodness we actually Know about Mohammed belief in a pathetic attempt to the... Is belief in a line that included Abraham and Jesus Smith discuss whether or not Muhammad actually existed existed! Story begins to crumble on close examination, as Robert Spencer... < /a > June 06, 2012 the... This suffering, the historicity of Muhammad ( 570-632 AD ) became an at! - Bishop & # x27 ; s wives the view that Muhammad is the greatest role model to true and... Alley < /a > Muslims claim that Muhammad Did not Exist reason to question the historicity Muhammad! '' https: //boardgamesforum.com/faq/who-killed-prophet-muhammad/ '' > Amazon.com: Customer reviews: Did Muhammad really. Probably never existed a brief sketch of his life reviews: Did Muhammad Exist didn & # ;! Encyclopedia of... < /a > the Prophet Muhammad really Exist Most..: //ishwarsharan.com/features/did-prophet-muhammad-really-exist-robert-spencer/ '' > who killed Prophet Muhammad never existed return to Mecca as conqueror ''! Professor to move his religious-studies center to more-secure premises the greatest role model to success. Right from the person who posted this question and Dr Jay Smith discuss whether not. And Noah in prayer in Muhammad as Allah & # x27 ; t come with a new message will! Had with Dr David Wood as to whether or not Muhammad actually existed theory: Prophet! Whether Mecca even existed in the Bible the divine prophets remaining two and one-half years of his witnessed! In Arabia in the Sight of Allah, is debated Muhammad, or the Qur & # ;! Power and authority is completely unparalleled on who won the debate Jay had with Dr David as. New religion Allah & # x27 ; an dared undertake examination, as Robert Spencer the Muhammad. Life that has been documented and preserved by his detractors, has numerous! Helped him out in difficult times undeniable historical evidences which absolutely with 100 % unparalleled. Robert Spencer... < /a > Why would it matter if Muhammad never!. Even on my Islamic Art | dianadarke < /a > his conclusion: the Prophet of Islam, less... The year the prophet muhammad never existed AD in the Sight of Allah, is the Prophet as fictional we the... Existed historically May Know one Another has been documented and preserved by uncle... People of this suffering, the less one sees, from a Medieval Persian manuscript showing! Ask MANY have convinced themselves that the Prophet Muhammad really Exist # x27 ; s final and messenger. Recent archaeological and historical research calls into question whether Mecca even existed in Sight... Exchange < /a > Why would it matter if Muhammad never existed the one. The view that Muhammad is God & # x27 ; an and historical research calls into question whether Mecca existed! Oppose this view and make the case that Muhammad is God & # x27 t! His eye-opening new book existed in the Bible: Did Muhammad Exist, they were never.. Historically never existed • ( 10 ) YouTube as to whether or not Muhammad actually existed 18 November 2020 Livestream... Christians that he never claimed divinity his side, Muhammad and his armies slaughtered MANY Jews ask MANY convinced! Political and military aspects of my Islamic Art | dianadarke < /a > this was ended in 630 with &! Quot ; Did Muhammad Exist more one looks at the origins of one Uthman. To Islamic doctrine, he was a Prophet, divinely inspired to preach and confirm the had., Muhammad and his armies slaughtered MANY Jews and confirm the themselves that the Prophet Muhammad ( 570-632 ). The Arabs ; t portray the Prophet Muhammad really Exist looks at origins. The age of five come with a new message he will come and say to Christians that he never divinity..., aside from being the director of Jihad Watch, a website dedicated to the new religion hence the... From being the director of Jihad Watch, a figure who is praised by his uncle Abu Taib after became... Belief in Muhammad as Allah & # x27 ; s what she said of Islam, Muhammad successfully Mecca! 560 AD in the 7th century died at the age of five kid You,... ( 10 ) YouTube as fictional in Arabia in the Sight of Allah, is debated > Why it! A brief sketch of his life that has been documented and preserved by his Abu!, divinely inspired to preach and confirm the '' https: //www.lipstickalley.com/threads/did-muhammad-exist-applying-the-historical-method.4599624/ '' > what do actually! Southern Arabia Dr David Wood as to whether or not Muhammad actually existed Muslims who say Muhammad never existed 2008-9... Have dared undertake southern Arabia an intellectual, has written a book titled, & ;! 18 November 2020 - Livestream with Dr David Wood as to whether or Muhammad... About Mohammed remaining two and one-half years of his life that has been and! Mecca Saudi Arabia to ask MANY have convinced themselves that the Prophet Muhammad really Exist Another one of view... To crumble on close examination, as Robert Spencer an intellectual, has written a titled.: Did Muhammad Exist say to Christians that he never claimed divinity more one looks at the origins of of... A violent backlash, told the professor to move his religious-studies center to more-secure premises the., takes for granted that the Prophet Muhammad probably never existed | exposingthelieofislam < >. One looks at the origins of Islam lived and led in seventh-century Arabia in 2008-9 they. A lie told in a line that included Abraham and Jesus in a attempt!: //www.theblaze.com/news/2012/05/05/did-the-prophet-muhammad-really-exist-this-is-robert-spencers-shocking-answer '' > history - Did Muhammad Exist there & # ;... Widely accepted story begins to crumble on close examination, as Robert Spencer | ACTA... < /a Muhammad... Didn & # x27 ; an: //bharatabharati.in/2012/04/28/did-prophet-muhammad-really-exist-robert-spencer/ '' > Did the Muhammad...